Guide
Are photo vault apps safe? Five checks
Some are and some aren’t, and you can tell before you install. Check five things: whether the app encrypts the files it stores or only locks a screen, whether it names its cipher, where the keys live, whether it needs an account or a server, and what its backup does. A listing that only says encrypted, with no cipher and no word about keys, has not answered the question.
On this page
The five checks
Each check says what to look for, what vault listings tend to say, and how Sealed answers. The listing findings come from the Photo Vault Audit, which counted the claims in sixteen App Store listings and keeps each count next to its quotes.
Check 1: Is it encrypted, or only locked?
A code screen decides who can use the app. Encryption decides whether the stored files mean anything to someone who gets past that screen, or who copies them off the phone. Look for the word encrypted about the files in the vault, not only about a cloud backup.
What listings say. In the audit, most listings used the word for the vault’s own files, a few used it only for a cloud backup, and some never used it.
How Sealed answers. Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Names, notes and the fields of a record are sealed with your vault key too, not just the photos.
Check 2: Does it name the cipher?
Encrypted is a claim. A cipher is something you can look up. GCM, the mode in AES-256-GCM, is defined in NIST’s SP 800-38D as an algorithm for authenticated encryption: it scrambles the data and also detects any change to it.
What listings say. Only two of the sixteen named a cipher. More of them leaned on borrowed authority (“the encryption banks use”), absolutes such as impenetrable, or superlatives such as most secure. None of those phrases tells you how the files are stored.
How Sealed answers. Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Each file gets its own random 256-bit key, and that key is sealed with your vault key. Large files are encrypted in chunks, and Sealed refuses a file that has been changed, reordered or cut short.
Check 3: Where do the keys live?
Whoever holds the key can read the files. Ask whether the key stays on your phone or sits on the developer’s server, and what an email reset would unlock: the app, or the files themselves.
What listings say. Almost nothing. A listing can’t show where an app keeps its keys, so this check needs the app’s own documentation.
How Sealed answers. Your vault key is kept in the iPhone Keychain, on this device only, and it can be read only while the phone is unlocked. Your vault key is a random 256-bit key. It is not made from your passcode. Your vault key never reaches us. Apple says keychain items in a class marked “This device only” are protected with the device’s own key when they are copied during a backup, which makes them useless if they are restored to a different device.
The honest limit: Without Maximum Security, the app can read your vault key whenever the phone is unlocked, because the key sits in the Keychain. Maximum Security seals your vault key to a Secure Enclave key that can be used only after a live Face ID or Touch ID match.
Check 4: Does it need an account or a server?
An account, or a server in the middle, is one more place your photos or your keys could be. Look for a sign-up, for recovery by email, and for the privacy section on the app’s App Store page. Apple says that section is self-reported by the developer and shows some of the data types an app may collect, so read it as the developer’s own statement.
What listings say. Recovery varied widely: a few listings sent you through an email address, a few said there was no way back, one sold a password reset, and half didn’t say. More than half showed ads or sold ad removal. An app that holds your photos and shows ads deserves a close look at its privacy section.
How Sealed answers. Sealed has no account, so there is nothing to sign up for. We run no server, so there is nothing of yours for us to see. Sealed contains no analytics or tracking SDKs, and it collects no data.
Check 5: What does the backup do?
Ask three things. Is the backup encrypted before it leaves your phone? Whose account holds it? What happens to your photos if you delete the app or lose the phone?
What listings say. Fewer than half warned that deleting the app or losing the phone can lose the photos. Silence is not the same as safety: it only means the listing doesn’t say.
How Sealed answers. Backup goes to your own iCloud account, not to a server of ours. Files, names, notes and record fields are encrypted on your iPhone before they are uploaded, so iCloud receives only ciphertext. The first time you save your recovery key, Sealed also turns on iCloud Backup, which is free. If you delete Sealed from an iPhone while iCloud Backup is off, the vault on that iPhone is deleted with it. The recovery key is the only way to decrypt an iCloud backup on a new iPhone.
What a listing can’t tell you
A listing is what a developer chose to write. It can say encrypted without naming a cipher, and stay silent about where keys live. Before you trust any vault with something you can’t replace:
- Read the privacy section on its App Store page and the developer’s privacy policy.
- Look at the version history. An app that hasn’t been updated in a long time may not match its own description.
- Ask how you get back in if you forget the passcode, and what a restore on a new phone needs. How to compare photo vault apps lists the questions.
- Put in a few test photos first, then delete and restore them, before you move the rest.
Where Sealed helps, and where it doesn’t
It helps by answering each of the five checks in writing, from the app’s code and listing. Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Sealed has no account, so there is nothing to sign up for. The rest is in how your photos are protected and on the security page.
It doesn’t make any photo safe once it leaves the vault. Your files never leave your iPhone unless you turn on iCloud backup or export them yourself. The original in Photos, a photo you sent in a chat and anything you export are outside it.
It doesn’t have a way to reset your access for you. Because your key never reaches us, we cannot recover your vault or reset your passcode for you.
It hasn’t been checked by an outside auditor. Sealed has not had an independent security audit. The encryption specification is the place to start if you want to check its claims.
Questions and answers
Is a photo vault app safe?
It depends on the app, and a listing alone can’t settle it. Check five things: encrypted or only locked, the cipher named, where the keys live, an account or a server, and what the backup does. Sealed’s answers are written down. Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Your vault key is kept in the iPhone Keychain, on this device only, and it can be read only while the phone is unlocked. We run no server, so there is nothing of yours for us to see. Files, names, notes and record fields are encrypted on your iPhone before they are uploaded, so iCloud receives only ciphertext.
Can I trust a forum thread that says an app is safe?
A thread tells you what other people experienced. It can’t show how an app encrypts, where its keys live or what its backup does. The five checks take a few minutes, using the app’s page and its settings.
Is Sealed safe?
No app can promise that in every case. Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Your vault key is kept in the iPhone Keychain, on this device only, and it can be read only while the phone is unlocked. We run no server, so there is nothing of yours for us to see. Its limits, such as copies that leave the vault, are on the page about how Sealed protects your photos.
Sources
What this page says about Sealed was checked against the app on .
- NIST SP 800-38D, Galois/Counter Mode — defines GCM, an algorithm for authenticated encryption with associated data (published November 2007). Read 13 Nov 2026
- Apple Support, About privacy information on the App Store — the privacy information on an app’s page is self-reported by the developer, and shows some of the data types the app may collect (published September 16, 2024). Read 13 Nov 2026
- Sealed on the App Store — the listing, which answers the five checks for Sealed
Get Sealed
Sealed is free to download, and Sealed Pro is an optional in-app purchase.