Study
The Photo Vault Audit: what 16 App Store listings promise (October 2026)
What do photo vault listings promise about encryption, accounts, deletion and passwords? We read the text of 16 listings on the US App Store on 28 October 2026. 11 of 16 use the word encrypted, and 2 of 16 name the cipher. 6 of 16 warn that photos can be lost, and 4 of those name deleting the app. 3 of 16 tie recovery to an email address, and 8 of 16 do not say how a forgotten passcode or a lost device is recovered. We read listings, not apps.
On this page
How the audit was done
What was read. For each of the 16 listings we saved the text of its page on the US App Store: the title, the subtitle, the promotional text where there is one, the description, the names of the in-app purchases, the “Contains” line of the age rating, and the offer text of the one featured subscription. We did not read screenshots, preview videos, release notes, reviews, privacy labels or the websites a listing links to. We did not sign in, buy anything or contact anyone.
When and where. Every page was read on 28 October 2026, from the US storefront. A listing can change on any day, and promotional text can change without a new release.
What counts as a claim. We put 9 yes-or-no questions to every text. “Yes” means the text says it, and the data holds the exact words. “No” means we searched the whole text and it does not say it, or says the opposite. “Unclear” means the text is silent or ambiguous on something that cannot be read off silence. This page reports 8 of the 9 questions. The ninth, about listings that present the app as looking like another kind of app, is in the data files and is not reported here.
Who judged. An AI model (Claude) read each listing in full and answered the questions by written rules. No second reader has checked its answers. A script then checked that every quote is an exact copy of text in the saved listing.
How the 16 were chosen. 14 come from the competitor table in Loopware’s own research notes of 1 October 2026. We added 2 on 28 October: L16, by name, and L12, the vault app that ranked best across 4 searches of the US store among those not already on the list. The searches are listed in the method notes that go with the data. These 16 are not a random sample of vault apps.
The 16 listings
We name each listing by its App Store id, not by its title. L1 to L16 follow US rating count on 28 October 2026, highest first, and these numbers are used in every table below. Each id links to Apple’s public lookup record for the listing, as it reads now. To check a quote from a description, search the record’s description field. Promotional text, subtitles and the list of in-app purchases are on the store page, not in the record.
| No. | App Store id | Last updated | US ratings |
|---|---|---|---|
| L1 | 417571834 | 1,018,412 | |
| L2 | 510873505 | 385,214 | |
| L3 | 1186436980 | 76,582 | |
| L4 | 1449239240 | 69,995 | |
| L5 | 1174964304 | 38,910 | |
| L6 | 867586326 | 30,290 | |
| L7 | 1165276801 | 28,931 | |
| L8 | 427701370 | 26,335 | |
| L9 | 1195429570 | 24,904 | |
| L10 | 523488488 | 24,790 | |
| L11 | 1254051789 | 23,508 | |
| L12 | 1459036428 | 14,181 | |
| L13 | 1462756877 | 13,707 | |
| L14 | 513852898 | 8,766 | |
| L15 | 1491039513 | 2,571 | |
| L16 | 6758529311 | 53 |
The counts
Each row is one question put to all 16 listings. Of 16 is how many listings the text answers with the row’s answer. Which lists them by the numbers above. Under each claim are its name in claims.json (a key of apps[].claims) and the setting that picks the row. The names are the data’s own labels. A row that begins “Of these” is part of the row above it, and where the text under a table says so, one listing can sit in more than one row.
Encryption
| Claim and its field | Of 16 | Which |
|---|---|---|
Uses the word encrypt, encrypted or encryption says_ value = true | 11 | L1, L2, L3, L5, L6, L8, L12, L13, L14, L15, L16 |
Of these, for the files the app stores says_ scope = stored_ | 9 | L2, L3, L5, L6, L12, L13, L14, L15, L16 |
Of these, only for its cloud backup says_ scope = cloud_ | 2 | L1, L8 |
Never uses the word says_ value = false | 5 | L4, L7, L9, L10, L11 |
Names a cipher names_ value = true | 2 | L15, L16 |
Makes a claim of borrowed authority, an absolute, or “the most secure” hyperbole value = true | 9 | L1, L2, L7, L8, L9, L10, L12, L14, L15 |
Of these, borrowed authority (bank, government or military standards) hyperbole evidence kind = borrowed_ | 2 | L2, L15 |
Of these, an absolute (such as impenetrable, impossible, complete, guaranteed) hyperbole evidence kind = absolute | 5 | L1, L7, L8, L10, L15 |
Of these, a security superlative (such as the most secure, the best encryption) hyperbole evidence kind = security_ | 5 | L1, L9, L12, L14, L15 |
The three kinds of claim overlap: a listing can make more than one. A popularity claim, a feature claim and a reassuring sentence are not counted. The phrases we did not count are kept in the data as borderline.
How the word and the claims read, in the listings’ own words:
“The encrypted storage can be accessed only when you enter your particular digit-passcode.” — L3, id 1186436980
“truly safe and encrypted with AES CTR” — L15, id 1491039513
“behind an impenetrable lock screen” — L10, id 523488488
“the most secure and private app in the App Store” — L9, id 1195429570
“The same encryption that is used by banks and governments worldwide!” — L15, id 1491039513
L15 and L16 are the 2 that name a cipher.
Deleting the app or losing the device
| Claim and its field | Of 16 | Which |
|---|---|---|
Warns that photos can be lost: after deleting the app, losing the device or forgetting a password deleting_ value = true | 6 | L1, L4, L6, L8, L11, L13 |
Of these, name deleting the app deleting_ scope includes app_ | 4 | L4, L6, L11, L13 |
Of these, warn only about a backup password or a lost device deleting_ scope without app_ | 2 | L1, L8 |
Carries no such warning deleting_ value = false | 10 | L2, L3, L5, L7, L9, L10, L12, L14, L15, L16 |
“Carries no such warning” means the text has none. It does not say what the app does when it is deleted.
“If you delete the app, your photos & data saved in the app will also be deleted.” — L4, id 1449239240
“deleting the app will result in losing your personal data.” — L13, id 1462756877
Forgotten passcodes and accounts
| Claim and its field | Of 16 | Which |
|---|---|---|
Ties recovery to an email address account_ route = email | 3 | L5, L6, L7 |
Names a way back that needs no email or account (a Touch ID reset) account_ route = biometric_ | 1 | L12 |
Says access or data is lost if a password or PIN is forgotten (L1 and L8 mean their cloud backup password) account_ route = no_ | 3 | L1, L8, L11 |
Sells a password reset as an in-app purchase, without describing it account_ route = paid_ | 1 | L10 |
Does not say how a forgotten passcode or a lost device is recovered account_ route = not_ | 8 | L2, L3, L4, L9, L13, L14, L15, L16 |
The five rows cover all 16 listings, once each. Of the 3 that tie recovery to an email address, L6 and L7 use it for a forgotten or lost password and L5 uses it to restore a cloud copy.
“You can conveniently retrieve your lost password through your registered email.” — L7, id 1165276801
“If you forget your gesture PIN, you can reset with Touch ID.” — L12, id 1459036428
“You will not be able to access your Locker if you choose not to set up FaceID / TouchID and you forget your PIN.” — L11, id 1254051789
Money and ads
Plans and ads are counted from the description, the names of the in-app purchases, the age rating and the offer text of the featured subscription.
| Claim and its field | Of 16 | Which |
|---|---|---|
States a price in money in the description prices_ value = true | 3 | L4, L7, L14 |
Has a weekly plan (named in the text, an in-app purchase or the featured subscription’s offer) weekly_ value = true | 3 | L4, L15, L16 |
States its plans, and weekly is not one of them weekly_ value = false | 9 | L2, L3, L6, L7, L10, L11, L12, L13, L14 |
Shows no billing periods, so a weekly plan can be neither shown nor ruled out weekly_ value = null | 4 | L1, L5, L8, L9 |
Says the app shows ads, sells ad removal, or lists “Advertising” in its age rating ads value = true | 9 | L1, L2, L3, L4, L6, L7, L8, L14, L15 |
Of these, only through the age rating ads kinds = age_ | 5 | L1, L4, L8, L14, L15 |
Says there are no ads ads kinds include no_ | 2 | L13, L16 |
What this study cannot tell you
- A listing is not the app. It is what the developer wrote. A listing that says nothing on a point may still do it, and a listing that says it may not. We did not install or test any of the 16 apps.
- A “no” is about the text. It means the text does not say it, never that the app lacks it.
- One country, one day. US storefront, 28 October 2026. Other countries, other languages and other days may read differently.
- Not a sample. 14 of the 16 are competitors we chose, and we added 2. The counts describe these 16, not vault apps in general.
- One reader, written rules. The answers are an AI model’s, with no second reader. The rules decide the counts: another rule for what counts as an absolute, or as a warning, would give other numbers.
- Not everything was read. A claim made only in a screenshot, a video, the release notes, the reviews, the privacy label or a linked website is not counted. For 4 listings the first paragraph is treated as promotional text, which the store does not label. The store page lists in-app purchases by name and price only and seems to stop at 10, and 7 listings show exactly 10, which is why 4 listings are unclear on weekly plans.
- Questions not asked. The audit did not count how many listings say that no account is needed.
- Not independent. L1 and L8 come from the same developer and share much of their text, so a count that includes both is not two separate observations.
- Old text. 2 listings, L3 and L12, were last updated more than a year before the audit, so their text may describe an older app.
Who made this, and how to correct it
Sealed is made by Loopware LLC. The app is called Sealed, and its App Store name is Sealed: Private Photo Vault. It competes with the apps in this study. It is not one of the 16, and no number on this page is a count for Sealed. Its listing was not read for this study.
We chose the apps, set the 9 questions and ran the audit, so we have a stake in the result. That is why each count carries its quotes, its field and its rule, and why you can check any of them against the live listing. If Sealed’s own listing is added to this audit, it will be read with the same 9 questions and the same rules, its quotes will be shown, and this page will say when it was added.
To correct us, write to support@loopware.app or use the support page. Give the listing number or App Store id and the sentence you think we misread. We will read that listing again, fix the count if it is wrong, and say on this page what changed and when.
Where Sealed helps, and where it doesn’t
It helps when you want a vault that answers these questions in plain words. Sealed encrypts every file with AES-256-GCM before it is saved. Sealed has no account, so there is nothing to sign up for. If you forget your passcode, your recovery key lets you set a new one. The security page says what each protection does and where it stops, and the five questions to ask any photo vault work on any listing.
It doesn’t change what this audit can tell you. It counted words, and what Sealed says about itself is text we wrote, so it needs the same checking. Sealed has limits of its own on the points above. If you delete Sealed from an iPhone while iCloud Backup is off, the vault on that iPhone is deleted with it. Because your key never reaches us, we cannot recover your vault or reset your passcode for you.
Sources
What this page says about Sealed was checked against the app on .
- App Store lookup, L1 (id 417571834) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L2 (id 510873505) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L3 (id 1186436980) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L4 (id 1449239240) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L5 (id 1174964304) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L6 (id 867586326) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L7 (id 1165276801) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L8 (id 427701370) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L9 (id 1195429570) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L10 (id 523488488) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L11 (id 1254051789) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L12 (id 1459036428) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L13 (id 1462756877) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L14 (id 513852898) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L15 (id 1491039513) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- App Store lookup, L16 (id 6758529311) — name, developer, version, last update and description, read 28 October 2026
- Apple, App Store Connect Help: platform version information — promotional text can be changed without an updated submission, read 28 October 2026
Get Sealed
Sealed is free to download, and Sealed Pro is an optional in-app purchase.