Guide · Choosing a vault

Vendor lock-in and photo apps: how to keep the way out open

Vendor lock-in is when leaving an app costs you so much effort, money or data that you stay even if you’d rather go. In photo apps it shows up as exports that strip quality or dates, formats only one app reads, and paywalls on getting your own files out. Before you trust an app with years of photos, check that you can export full-quality originals, in bulk, without paying, and ideally open them without the app.

Last checked

On this page

What lock-in looks like in a photo app

Nobody calls it lock-in on the sign-up screen. It shows up when you try to leave. Common signs:

  • Exports that lose something. Photos come out smaller, recompressed, or stripped of the date they were taken.
  • One at a time only. Saving a library of thousands means thousands of taps.
  • A format only the app reads. Files on disk with random names that open nowhere else, and no written description of what is in them.
  • A paywall on the exit. Viewing or exporting stops when a subscription ends.
  • An account that holds everything. If the company closes the account, the photos go too.

None of these is rare. Each one turns “I’ll switch later” into “I’ll stay”.

Why photos are a special case

A document can be retyped. A photo of a day that is over can’t be taken again. Libraries also grow for years, so the cost of leaving grows with them. The Ink & Switch essay on local-first software names this concern “The Long Now”: data you made should outlive the software you made it with.

The checks that keep you free

Run these before you move a large library anywhere.

  1. Export a few test photos and look at them on a computer. Same size and resolution? Date still there?
  2. Look for bulk export. Can you select everything at once?
  3. Read what export costs. Is it free on every plan, including after a subscription ends?
  4. Find the format. Is there a written description of how files are stored, or an independent tool that opens them?
  5. Find your copy of the key. If the files are encrypted, you need the key, not just the app, to open them.

The guide to exporting from a vault app has the steps for the export itself.

Big platforms have exits too

Large services usually offer a full download. Apple, for example, lets you request a copy of your data at privacy.apple.com, and says photos and videos come back in their original formats. Use these tools now and then, not only on the day you leave: they show you what an exit would really hand you.

What a fair exit looks like

A fair app makes three promises and keeps them:

  1. Your originals come out as they went in, in bulk, on every plan.
  2. The storage format is written down, so others can build a reader.
  3. The data opens without the company, if the company is gone.

Few apps manage the third. It matters most for apps that encrypt, because an encrypted library with no other reader is lock-in by design. How you pay plays a part too: subscription or one-time purchase looks at what each means for your files.

Where Sealed helps, and where it doesn’t

It helps because getting your own photos out never needs a plan. Viewing and exporting your own photos is always free. In an open item, Export and then Export Unlocked Copy hands a decrypted copy of that one item to the iOS share sheet.

It helps with a copy that opens with your recovery key and a free reader, no app required. The open copy keeps a copy of your vault in your iCloud Drive, in a folder named Sealed, that opens without the app on any computer, with your recovery key and the Sealed reader. The reader is open source and travels inside every open copy, as a Python script and an offline web page. The open copy page explains it, and the encryption specification describes the formats.

It doesn’t keep that copy current on its own until you turn it on. The open copy is off until you turn it on, and the automatic copy starts only once your recovery key is saved.

It doesn’t remove the need for your key. Without it, the open copy stays locked. Because your key never reaches us, we cannot recover your vault or reset your passcode for you.

Questions and answers

Is an encrypted format a form of lock-in?

Only if nobody can open it but the app. An encrypted format with a published description and an independent reader can be opened by anyone who has the key.

Should I avoid subscriptions to avoid lock-in?

A subscription is not lock-in by itself. What matters is what happens to your files when it ends. In Sealed: Viewing and exporting your own photos is always free.

How do I test an app’s export before I rely on it?

Add a handful of photos, export them, and check the copies on a computer: size, date, location and format. Do it in the first week, not the last.

Sources

What this page says about Sealed was checked against the app on .

Last checked:

Get Sealed

Sealed is free to download, and Sealed Pro is an optional in-app purchase.